Project Title: A Study of Liminal Space in the Architecture of Transportation Facilities
BASIS Advisor: Mr. Opirhory
Internship Location: Davies-Toews Architecture
Onsite Mentor: Jonathan Toews
Despite being a necessity of modern living, many Americans find traveling stressful. A factor specific to transportation architecture that may account for some of this stress is the concept of the liminal space. In-between and connecting recognizable destinations, a liminal space can be described as a“non-destination” where a rite of passage, such as travel, has become entrenched in the way individuals understand that environment. As users spend time in a liminal space, expectations of continued transition from one point to the next may contribute to distress as the constructed purpose of the space remains unfulfilled. To account for liminal disorientation, the design of a transition space must incorporate elements that aim to re-establish that space as a unique destination. Under the mentorship of architect Jonathan Toews, this project will identify some of these potential design solutions through an examination of the architecture of four New York City transportation facilities. This examination will incorporate prior research into the concept of a liminal environment, as well as results from an online survey assessing users’ perceptive and emotional experience at each of the chosen facilities. I hope that my research will show how the distinct architectural approaches taken at each facility being studied influence a user’s experience of liminality, informing the approach I take to creating my own proposal for the design of a terminal. By identifying architectural approaches that work against liminal disorientation, I hope my findings provide a useful framework for the design of future transportation facilities.
My Posts
Conclusion
Last week, I officially gave my final presentation! This senior project has certainly been a journey from start to finish, from analytical writing to data science to developing my game using C# and Unity Engine. I’m very thankful for the senior project committee making this project possible; it is because of their continued support that […]
Week 10: Releasing My Design Project and an Overview of My Final Analysis
After lots of optimization work, I’m excited to share that I’ve released my design proposal on itch.io for anyone who is interested to play in their browser! https://thenoseofsauron.itch.io/transition-space-an-interactive-final-design-projectv2 I’ve also released some higher-quality builds for Mac and Windows which can be downloaded (the builds which I’ll ultimately showcase in my project presentation). What makes the […]
Week 9: “Sneak Peek” at My Final Project
This week I have been putting together my project using Unity 3D and a variety of other tools (like Blender for 3D modelling, Visual Studio for C# code and Logic Pro for sound design). So far I have created three “non-space” environments and a concept for a “sense of place” terminal based on my previous […]
Week 8: Design Proposal Update
Being a month away from the senior project presentation and about a week ahead of schedule as outlined on my syllabus, I took some time this week to focus on my final design proposal. As a refresher, I intend to submit a finished artwork conveying the results of my research through depictions of “sense of […]
Week 7: Analysis of Survey Responses in R and New Insights
After meeting on Monday with JT to review last week’s demo, I published my survey, hoping to receive around 100 responses before closing. Two days later, the survey had received 163 responses from Survey Monkey’s user audience, giving me lots of additional data to work with! As planned, I used a multiple linear regression to […]
Week 6: Survey Demonstration and Plans for Data Analysis
I focused on finalizing my survey this week and was able to produce a working demo – this version of the survey has a variety of changes from my original draft. Underpinning these changes were analytical considerations and, surprisingly, significant budget constraints: Survey Monkey charges about a dollar for each response, and access to certain […]
Week 5: Drafting a Survey for my Original Research
This week I began working on the next phase of my project, which will be an online survey assessing participants’ reactions to transition space in New York City transportation architecture. I plan to create and publish my survey through Survey Monkey. For each part of this survey, participants will be presented with a set of […]
Week 4: Using Asymmetry to Define Objects in Space
Continuing my two-week long investigation of transition spaces through image analysis, my goal for this week was to identify some of the visuals that might contribute to “sense of place”, or an awareness of being within a distinct location. Last week I discovered that architectural monotony and a faraway focal point can contribute to a […]
Week 3: Portrayals of Non-Space in Artwork
After learning about Phenomenology last week, I shifted my attention to art creation and analysis to practice with some of the interesting concepts I have been studying. My goal for Weeks 3 and 4 is to investigate the visuals that might differentiate uncomfortable “non-space” from restorative “sense of place” in transition spaces. This week, I […]
Week 2: Insights From Phenomenology
This week, I studied the area of Philosophy known as Phenomenology, which addresses how a person perceives and interacts with their real-world surroundings. To do this, I read from Dr. Chad Engelland’s “Phenomenology” while considering how the concepts discussed could apply to liminal space. While philosophers such as Descartes argued that it is impossible to […]
Week 1: Place Attachment and the Potential Transformative Implications of Water
During my research this week, I came across a presentation by human performance researcher Adam Fraser describing a transformative zone between work and home termed the “Third Space”. In the linked video, Dr. Fraser describes the results of his research investigating how taking time to mentally rest and reflect between distinct tasks can improve […]
Week 0: Introduction
Monday, March 29: Hi everyone! My name is Jacob Helzner, and I am excited to introduce you to my Senior Project on liminal space in transportation architecture. I am really looking forward to taking my first steps towards answering my research question this week. My question is as follows: “In transportation architecture, how do design […]